Controversial Call At French Open Sparks Hawk-Eye Debate - UBITENNIS
Connect with us

Hot Topics

Controversial Call At French Open Sparks Hawk-Eye Debate

Some are saying that it is time to use electronic line calling on the clay but how accurate is it really?




Barbora Krejcikova (image via

Multiple Grand Slam champion Chris Evert believes the French Open should implement a hawk-eye system in line with other tournaments following a controversial call made during one of the women’s semi-final matches.


The drama unfolded in the closing stages of Barbora Krejcikova’s marathon clash with Maria Sakkari. Leading the final set 8-7, the Czech thought she had won when a shot from Sakkari appeared to have drifted beyond the baseline. However, the umpire came to inspect the marking and ruled the ball to be in. Something which was then contradicted by Hawk-Eye live which is used by television networks.

Amid the drama Krejcikova managed to hold her nerve to seal a place in her first ever major final. Although if she had lost, the match official would have found himself under heavy criticism for what former world No.1 Andy Murray described on Twitter as a ‘brutal error.’

“Maybe this will be a lesson for the tournament to get Hawk-Eye now like they do at the three other Grand Slams,” Evert told Eurosport’s The Cube.
“During the whole tournament there have been some big points with bad lines calls. It’s not just this one time. That’s why I feel this system isn’t working right now.”

Krejcikova, who is currently ranked 33rd in the world, was informed of the controversy during her press conference. She said the challenge for her was trying to regroup after thinking she had won the match.

“No Hawk-Eye on clay, it’s difficult. Sometimes it helps, sometimes it doesn’t. I don’t know. It’s very difficult,” she commented.
“At that moment I was just, like, Well, it’s out, but what can you do? The chair umpire, he has seen it as in. What can I do? I cannot do anything about it. I cannot call anyone, change his decision.”

Three-time French Open champion Mats Wilander went as far as suggesting that Roland Garros should improve their officiating standards. In a direct jibe at the umpire on Eurosport he said ‘how do you miss a mark like that which is supposedly 19 millimetres out?’

Due to the nature of clay the French Open currently doesn’t need to rely on the use of electronic line-calling. Furthermore, Hawk-Eye live has not been given approval for use on the surface because the accuracy of their calls needs further verification. At present the only system that has been given the green light for use is Foxtenn’s Real Bounce which was used during the Madrid Open.

Although in Madrid there were some concerns over its accuracy among players, according to Sakkari.

We saw in Madrid that the Hawk-Eye (Foxtenn) they had there was not accurate at all. I spoke with other players. They said the same,” she told reporters on Thursday.
“If it’s accurate, then yes (use it on clay). If it’s not accurate, then there’s no point.”

Tournament director Guy Forget recently addressed the topic of electronic line calling where he stressed the importance of maintaining the ‘human element.’ The technology is seen by some as a replacement for linespeople who use their role as a step towards being an umpire.

“The bottom line, before doing anything new, is that it’s people’s jobs that we’re talking about,” he told ESPN. “It’s not just ‘machine versus a man’s eye.’ We have a very good way of teaching from a young age, a chair umpire and linesman. In our country, we have some of the best umpires and one of the reasons is that this is so consistent.”

The clay surface during a match can change due to the weather. For example, if it is windy the top layer in blown and therefore the ball markings explodes. Impacting how a computer monitors it. It is for reasons such as these why the use of electronic line calling remains a work in progress when it comes to the dirt.

Hot Topics

Naomi Osaka Withdraws From Wimbledon

In a statement issued by Osaka’s team, the tennis star has extended her decision to take a break from the sport amid mental health concerns.




On the same day of Rafael Nadal’s announcement, Naomi Osaka has become the latest big name to withdraw from the Wimbledon Championships.


The four-time Grand Slam champion has decided to miss the Grand Slam so she can take some ‘personal time’ away from the Tour, according to a statement issued by her team. Osaka recently revealed that she has been suffering from depression and social anxiety since 2018. The revelation came after a fallout erupted over her decision to not fulfil her press commitments at the French Open. She later withdrew from the tournament following her first round match due to mental health concerns.

However, Osaka has confirmed that she still intends to play at the Tokyo Olympic Games which will start towards the end of next month. She has been one the key athletes used by organisers to help promote the upcoming games.

“Naomi won’t be playing Wimbledon this year. She is taking some personal time with friends and family. She will be ready for the Olympics and is excited to play in front of her home fans.” A statement reads.

Despite her success in the majors, the 23-year-old is yet to go deep in the draw at Wimbledon. In her three previous appearances, she has reached the third round twice followed by a shock first round loss to Yulia Putintseva of Kazakhstan in 2019. The tournament wasn’t held last year due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Earlier this week Wimbledon organisers were hopeful that the world No.2 would play after reaching out to her team. Although they had no direct contact with Osaka herself. Tournament director Jamie Baker said he was open to ‘any discussions’ regarding potential issues that could arise.

“I had the conversation with her team,” AFP quoted Baker as saying on Wednesday. “It’s absolutely clear that we’re here, we’re completely open for any discussions when they want to have that. Hopefully it goes without saying that we want the best players competing here no matter what.”

Sportico reports that Osaka made $55M in earnings and endorsements during a 12-month period between 2020-2021. The highest amount ever to be earned by a female athlete during that period.

Osaka is yet to make any public commented following her withdrawal from Wimbledon.

Continue Reading

Hot Topics

Rafael Nadal to Skip Wimbledon and the Tokyo Olympics

“The fact that there has only been 2 weeks between RG and Wimbledon, didn’t make it easier on my body to recuperate”, has written the Spaniard in a statement.




Current world N.3 and 20-time Slam champion Rafa Nadal has decided not to play in the 2021 Championships nor in the re-scheduled 2020 Tokyo Olympics. In a series of Tweets, the Spaniard has made the news official while elaborating on the reasons behind this choice:


In a lengthy thread, he elaborated: “The goal is to prolong my career and continue to do what makes me happy, that is to compete at the highest level and keep fighting for those professional and personal goals at he maximum level of competition. The fact that there has only been 2 weeks between RG and Wimbledon, didn’t make it easier on my body to recuperate after the always demanding clay court season.

“They have been two months of great effort and the decision I take is focused looking at the mid and long term. Sport prevention of any kind of excess in my body is a very important factor at this stage of my career in order to try to keep fighting for the highest level of competition and titles”.

Nadal won in Barcelona and Rome, before bowing out against Novak Djokovic in a four-hours-and-eleven-minutes semifinal, ending an unbeaten run of 33 matches in Paris.

On the Tokyo event, he added: “The Olympic Games always meant a lot and they were always a priority as a Sports person, I found the spirit that every sports person in the world wants to live. I personally had the chance to live 3 of them and had the honor to be the flag bearer for my country.”

Nadal is a two-time Wimbledon champion (2008 and 2010) and has reached the semi-finals in the last two editions. This means that he will lose 360 points, since the Championships are among the tournaments that allow the players to keep 50 percent of their 2019 tallies under the revised ranking system.

He is also a two-time Olympic gold medalist: he won in the singles in Beijing in 2008 and in the doubles in Rio de Janeiro in 2016 partnering Marc Lopez – in Brazil, he also finished fourth in the singles event.

Continue Reading

Hot Topics

Frustrated Roger Federer Disappointed With Own Attitude Following Halle Loss

The former world No.1 reacts to his early exit from the Noventi Open.




Roger Federer says difficulty with his ongoing comeback from injury ‘got to him’ a little bit during his second round match at the Noventi Open in Halle.


The 10-time champion was knocked out of the tournament by Canada’s Felix Auger-Aliassime who prevailed 4-6, 6-3, 6-2. Making it the first time in Federer’s career he has failed to win back-to-back matches in the tournament. Halle was only the fourth tournament he has played since returning to the Tour following a knee injury which required two surgical procedures last year.

After getting knocked out of the tournament, the world’s media were left waiting for almost three hours before Federer spoke to the press. An unusual approach from a player who has lost. During that period the 39-year-old said he spoke with coach Ivan Ljubičić about his performance.

“I needed time to digest the third set. I was unhappy about how it ended,” he explained. “(It was) Similar to Geneva in some ways where I felt I actually played good in spells. But it was up and down.’
“That match had good and bad moments but I guess that’s part of the comeback.” He added.

Federer admitted that he started to get frustrated with himself after getting broken at the start of the decider where Auger-Aliassime went on to win four games in a row. He believes that mentality affected the outcome of the match but he gives credit to his Canadian opponent who registered only his fourth win over a top 10 player in his career.

“It was not a good attitude from my side. I was disappointed with the way I was feeling on court and the way things were going,” Federer admitted.
“I think the whole difficulty of the comeback got to me a little bit, as well. I realised that it was not going to be my day and there was nothing I could do. I started to get really negative. This is not normally how I am.’
“This is something I’m not happy about but at the same time in like 1500 of or so matches these things can happen. The good thing is that I know it will not happen the next time.”

The 20-time Grand Slam champion has recorded four wins this season heading into Wimbledon but only two of those were against top 50 players. He defeated Dan Evans (No.28) in Doha and Marin Cilic (No.47) at the French Open.

Federer will be returning back to his native Switzerland prior to travelling to the UK. Alluding to the fact that he doesn’t want to stay inside a bubble any longer than he has to. He will speak to his team about his next steps prior to Wimbledon, where he will be seeking a historic ninth title.

“The good thing coming out of a match like this against a great player is that I know what I need to think about moving forward because clearly I need do a bit better.” He concluded.

Continue Reading