Monte-Carlo Day Six: Chair umpire ruins semifinal match - UBITENNIS
Connect with us

Senza categoria

Monte-Carlo Day Six: Chair umpire ruins semifinal match




Rafael Nadal (

A controversial overrule decided the second semifinal at the Monte-Carlo Rolex Masters. Nadal claimed that one single point can’t decide an entire match. Goffin should have regrouped despite a massive mistake that the chair umpire made in a key moment of the first set.


MONTE-CARLO – After two disappointing semifinals, hopes are that tomorrow’s final will be an entertaining match, even if Rafael Nadal is the overwhelming favorite to win the title. Ramos Vinolas could experience a letdown after knocking out world No. 1 Andy Murray, dispatching No. 8 ranked Marin Cilic and prevailing over crowd favorite Lucas Pouille in order to reach his first final in a Masters 1000 event. Rafa leads the head-to-head against Ramos Vinolas 2-0; both meetings took place in Barcelona in 2013 and 2014 with Nadal overpowering his countryman 6-3, 6-0 and 7-6, 6-4. Playing Nadal on clay is probably the most difficult task in today’s modern game, especially in a tournament that the Mallorca native won nine times. It is also important to mention that Ramos Vinolas is now a much better player than in 2013 and 2014, when he lost nine matches in a row to his nemesis Fabio Fognini of Italy. Since reaching the quarterfinals at the 2016 French Open, Ramos Vinolas has been edging closer to the top of the game and will crack the top 20 for the first time in his career next week. Rafa dominated his competition the last two times that he played a fellow Spaniard in the Monte-Carlo final: In 2010 he overwhelmed Fernando Verdasco 6-0, 6-1 and in 2011 he prevailed over David Ferrer 6-4, 7-5.

Today’s second semifinal was decided by a crucial overrule by the chair umpire Mourier. The infamous call occurred when Goffin was up a break in the first set and Nadal hit a forehand that was 5 inches long and was correctly called out by the linesman. Nadal thought that the ball was out too and seemed ready to start serving in the next game. Had the umpire not overruled the linesman’s call, Goffin would have been up 4-2. While making a shocking decision, the umpire told Goffin that he wasn’t sure where the actual mark was and the point should have been replayed. Mourier’s attitude definitely contributed to the anger of the Belgian player, who is usually a true gentleman on the tennis court. It is amazing how Mourier made his decision without asking the linesman where the ball had actually landed.

“I gave the point to my opponent many times in the past in case the ball landed on my side of the court, but since that ball was on my opponent’s side, I couldn’t be 100% sure. I had to trust the chair umpire’s decision,” said Nadal after the match. “Rafa is one of the most correct players on the tour, it wasn’t his mistake. It was the chair umpire’s mistake,” explained Goffin, who should have regrouped instead of throwing away the match. After all, the controversial overrule came in the middle of the first set and the Belgian had plenty of time to mentally find his balance again.

Goffin paid for his inexperience in big matches. He should have given Nadal a more competitive match, especially after the extraordinary wins that the Belgian put together throughout the week. After defeating fellow coutryman Steve Darcis in his opening round, Goffin went on to beat clay-court specialist Nicolas Almagro of Spain, top-ten star Dominik Thiem of Austria and, last but not least,  world No. 2 and reigning French Open champion Novak Djokovic, whom he had never beaten in five previous matches.

Speaking of the Hawk-Eye system that has been officially in place since 2006 with the exception of the clay-court tournaments, Nadal said: “In my opinion Hawk-Eye would be in big trouble on clay!” In fact, while the system can offer an extremely accurate projection of where the ball lands, the mark left on the clay by the ball itself is probably more reliable.

If Nadal wins tomorrow’s final, he will conquer his 50th title on clay passing Guillermo Vilas for the all-time record. After Real Madrid won “La Decima” in the Champions League final three years ago, it is now Rafa’s turn to win his 10th title in the Principality.

(Article translation provided by T&L Global – Translation & Language Solutions – )

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Senza categoria

Svetlana Kuznetsova Wins First Title Since Return From Surgery In Washington

The two-time grand slam champion has returned back to the winners circle following her six-month absence due to injury.




Former world No.2 Svetlana Kuznetsova saved four match points to defeat Donna Vekic 4-6, 7-6(7), 6-2, in the final of the Citi Open in Washington.


Kuznetsova, 33, fought back against the aggressive play of her opponent. Saving seven out of the 10 break points she faced in the match. Eventually, it was the experience of the Russian that guided her to the finish line as she hit 34 winners to 36 unforced errors to win her first title on the tour since the 2016 Moscow Open.

“It was a difficult week,” Kuznetsova reflected afterwards. “Tennis is always mental, if you lose or if you win, you always gotta stay focused.”

With both players contesting their first final of the season, it was Vekic who battled through what was a roller-coaster and tense opening set. At first, the seventh seed appeared on course to clinch the opener with ease after breaking Kuznetsova in the fourth game as she raced out to a 4-1 lead. Only to be pegged by the 2014 champion. Serving for the set at 5-3, a forehand error rewarded Kuznetsova the chance to break back. Prior to the following point, the Russian complained about the movement of the crowd just as Vekic was about to serve. Then the Croat hit a double fault with the two players exchanging words at the changeover.

Despite feeling hard done by, Vekic soon restored order in the match. As Kuznetsova served for a chance to level 5-5, she pounced one again as the former world No.2 faltered. Recovering from a 15-40 deficit to seal the opening set with the help of a Kuznetsova double fault on set point.

Vekic continued to fight with the help of her of some rapid shock-making. Fending off a break point to nudge ahead 4-3 in the second set. Although Kuznetsova refused to go away. Saving two match points, it was in the tiebreaker where the Russian managed to turn her fortunes around. Vekic missed out on another two chances to win the match, allowing Kuznetsova to nudge ahead 8-7. She was then able to force proceedings into a decider after a Vekic forehand slammed into the net.

Kuznetsova’s resilience eventually wore her opponent down, who was close to tears after the match. Vekic admitted afterwards that she was dealing with leg pain and took a medical time out just before the start of the final set.

A double break in Kuznetsova’s favor in the decider guided her to a 5-0 lead. Enough of a cushion to enable her to close out the match after two-and-a-half hours of play to win her second Washington title.

“I know I’ve been a little bit lucky today,” she said.
“There’s something going on with Washington. I never lose here. I played two times and I won both.”

The victory comes after what has been a testing first half of the year for Kuznetsova. Left wrist surgery forced her to miss six months of the tour. Meaning that she didn’t start the 2018 season until March. Prior to the Citi Open, she had only won four matches in 10 tournaments played. Making her latest triumph even more special.

“Those times I had after the surgery, I had difficulties everywhere — personal, working different things. I switched coaches. I had lots of issues,” Kuznetsova explained. “But still, I rise again, and it’s really good for me.”

As a result of her latest win, Kuznetsova has risen 41 places in 87th in the world. Meanwhile, Vekic has jumped seven places to 37th.

Continue Reading

Davis Cup

Davis Cup Reforms Face Late Opposition As Vote Looms

The proposed Davis Cup reforms have received strong criticism from Tennis Australia and Tennis Europe ahead of this month’s vote.




David Haggerty (

The upcoming Davis Cup reform vote has received some strong opposition and criticism from Tennis Australia and Tennis Europe. 


The vote is set to take place on the 16th of August, where federations will vote to change the 118 year old format to a one week season finale at the end of the year. The proposed move by Kosmos, has received fierce criticism and will need a two-thirds majority in order for it to be approved.

However with the vote just two weeks away Tennis Australia has been among the federations to oppose these reforms and have pushed this even further as they have wrote a letter expressing their discontent at the idea. The letter has been signed by the likes of John Newcombe, current Davis Cup captain Lleyton Hewitt and Tennis Australia CEO Craig Tiley.

The letter raises the following concerns, “We have written and spoken to the ITF President for several months now requesting clarity on the proposal from Kosmos, but this has not been forthcoming,” explained the letter, which is even signed by former ITF president Brian Tobin.

“Very large numbers are being referenced, but there is not enough detail to give us confidence this proposal will genuinely deliver enough additional value to players and the nations to offset the loss of home and away camaraderie and all the local marketing, facility investment and player development benefit that comes with those ties. In the absence of such important information, we have no choice other than to vote against the proposed amendments.”

However Tennis Australia isn’t the only federation to be against this move as Tennis Europe, who represent more than 50 member nations have also expressed their concern at the idea, “I am particularly concerned that there is hardly any information received from the ITF regarding bank guarantees for the proposed US$120 million per year which would be the $3 billion deal over 25 years, according to the original proposal,” President Vladimir Dimitriev explained in a separate letter.

“I have not yet seen a final and feasible explanation on how the business model or the governance structure will be either.”

The ITF do have the backing of Germany and France ahead of the move though with the AGM meeting set to take place in Orlando, Florida between the 13th and 16th of August.

Continue Reading

Latest news

Serena Williams Withdraws From Montreal Due To Personal Reasons

Serena Williams has withdrawn from the Coupe Rogers in Montreal next week due to personal reasons.




Serena Williams (

Former world number one Serena Williams has withdrawn from the Coupe Rogers in Montreal next week as she deals with some personal issues. 


The American suffered the worst defeat of her career last week when she lost 6-1 6-0 to Johanna Konta in San Jose. The 23 grand slam champion clearly wasn’t at her best and it now turns out that she had personal problems to deal with as this is the reason for her withdrawal in Montreal next week.

The recent Wimbledon finalist also felt that she could not play Montreal and Cincinnati in back to back weeks as she continues her comeback from pregnancy. The tournament director, Eugene Lapierre, admits that he is disappointed but still recognises the high quality field that is left, “Of course, we are disappointed that Serena will not be joining us, Fans were very much looking forward to seeing her in action,” explained Eugene.

“But beyond the disappointment, the tournament, as a whole, remains a high-level competition. The entire Top 10 is here, along with 22 of the Top 25. There are exciting matches in store from the outset.”

The American was set to play in Canada for the first time since 2015 before withdrawing today. The 23 time grand slam champion has played five events since returning from pregnancy and the results have been mixed as you can see below:

Indian Wells – Third Round

Miami – First Round

Roland Garros – Fourth Round

Wimbledon – Final

San Jose – First Round

Tatjana Maria will now replace Serena Williams in the main draw and the German faces Alize Cornet in the first round.

Continue Reading